Trump Promise Demolished: Deficit Skyrockets After GOP Tax Scam | The Beat With Ari Melber | MSNBC
GOP, Trump tax law budget deficit promise falls apart
- The Treasury Department reported that the budget deficit grew to 9 billion in fiscal 2019.
- A primary reason for the increase in the deficit was a decrease in revenue due to the GOP tax law.
- The evidence so far contradicts Republicans leaders and the Trump administration's argument that the tax law would pay for itself.
- While there may still be a revenue boost from the law, the early returns do not look encouraging, and most forecasters expect the deficit to grow.
Republicans said their tax law was supposed to pay for itself. But according to new data from the Treasury Department, their overhaul of the tax code isn't producing the desired result.
The Treasury said the budget deficit hit 9 billion for fiscal 2019 — which was October 2019 through September 2019 — the highest level since 2012.
A significant part of the deficit increase was due to anemic revenue growth, largely from big tax cuts from the new GOP-led tax law, which went into effect earlier this year.
Particularly significant is the corporate tax side of the ledger, where the effects of the law have already taken hold. While most Americans have not yet filed their taxes under the new system, corporations pay taxes quarterly and have already been operating under the new lower rate.
According to Treasury data, tax revenue from corporate returns dropped 31% in fiscal 2019 compared with fiscal 2019. Meanwhile, individual tax revenue was up 6.1%, and total revenue increased by just 0.4% from fiscal 2019.
An analysis by the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget found that the revenue increase was historically low.
"This revenue growth rate is the eighth lowest in the past 50 years, and the seven lower years either coincided with a recession or tax cuts/expiring tax increases enacted shortly after a recession," the report said. "As we have noted, though, even this slight revenue growth understates how much the 2019 tax law is reducing revenue since the fiscal year totals include revenue raised from the pre-tax law code."
Republican leaders and the Trump administration said last year that the increased economic growth due to the tax bill would cause more money to flow to businesses and people, producing more tax revenue.
Even after several nonpartisan think tanks and the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office estimated that the bill would add to the federal deficit, Republican leaders remained steadfast in saying the tax cuts would eventually pay for themselves or even reduce the deficit.
"I not only don't think it will increase the deficit, I think it will be beyond revenue-neutral," Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said on December 4. "In other words, I think it will produce more than enough to fill that gap."
In August, Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin said the law would end up reducing the deficit.
"So we're humming along on where projections are, and as I've said, at 3% economic growth, this tax plan will not only pay for itself but in fact create additional revenue for the government," he said in an interview with CNBC.
The CBO expects the deficit to expand to 3 billion in fiscal 2019, with 8 billion due to reduced revenue as a result of the GOP tax law.
But it's still early — the tax law hasn't yet been in effect for a full year, and a revenue boost could come later.
Daniel Clifton, an expert on economic policy at Strategas Research Partners, pointed out that the positive economic feedback and revenue boost from the 2003 tax-cut package did not take effect until a full year after it passed.
"Over 5 years, the projected 7bn cost of the 03 tax cut never materialized," Clifton tweeted Tuesday, adding that because of higher levels of economic growth and capital gains tax revenue, tax revenue exceeded pre-tax-cut expectations.
"The 17 tax change did not include cap gains tax cut," he said. "Feedback effect will be less but strong."
But for the revenue side of the ledger to pick up significantly, there would need to be a sustained increase in gross-domestic-product growth, which few forecasters are projecting.
Video: Budget Deficit Soars To 6-Year High Under President Donald Trump | The Last Word | MSNBC
This Single Girl’s Very Single Christmas Cards Are Kind Of Amazing
The Victoria’s Secret Models We Miss Walking in the VS Fashion Show
What You Can Learn From Your Mothers Menopause
Short Haircuts For Thin Hair That You Will Love
The Fittest Personality Type
Pancreatic Radiation Therapy in Kids Carries Diabetes Risk
How to Encourage Your Child to Eat Healthy Snacks
How to Get Rid of People That Hate You
How to Fold an Ironing Board
Celebs Demo How to Pull Off Vibrant Makeup Looks
6 Reasons to Add Almonds to Your Diet
Fendi Pre-Fall 2019 Collection Focuses On Innovative, Yet Classic Silhouettes
Dont Miss This Deadline
Cringe: Gwyneth Paltrow is Selling 1,695 Rap-ThemedClutches
Product Roundup: The Top 20 Best TravelNecessities